Bride and groom with dont give up sign thinking of choosing a Wedding Photographer

How to Choose a Wedding Photographer: What We’d Actually Tell a Friend

How to Choose a Wedding Photographer: What We’d Actually Tell a Friend

People ask us this more than you’d think. Usually friends, not clients. Someone’s daughter gets engaged, a coworker starts planning, and they end up asking us how to actually find the right photographer. Not the polished version. The real version.

So here it is. The advice we’d give if it were someone we loved making this decision.

We shoot documentary and candid wedding photography, so our perspective is shaped by that. We’ve tried to make this useful regardless of the style you’re drawn to. Choosing the right photographer matters more than choosing our style, and the process is largely the same either way.


Phase 1: Look Wide

Finding photographers who draw you in

Most couples start looking with only a vague sense of what they want. That’s fine. Phase one isn’t about making a decision. It’s about figuring out what pulls at you.

Look everywhere at first. Instagram, Google, your venue’s recommended vendor list, friends’ wedding albums, wedding blogs. If a photo stops you mid-scroll, pay attention to who took it. Start keeping a list of names. Do this before you’re ready to book, ideally before you even have a date. You’ll start to notice patterns in what you’re drawn to, and those patterns will tell you more about what you actually want than any questionnaire will.

When you’re looking at portfolios, don’t stop at the hero shots. Any photographer can put together a highlights reel that looks great. Look for full galleries if they’re available, or at minimum a broad cross-section of a wedding: getting ready, ceremony, portraits, reception, dancing. A portfolio that’s mostly beautiful couple portraits in golden hour tells you very little about what they do for the other seven hours of your day. You want to see how they handle low light, candid moments, group chaos, the quiet in-between parts. That’s where real skill shows, and that’s where most of your day actually lives.

This is also the phase where you start thinking about style, not just “I like their photos” but why you like them, and what that says about what you want from your own wedding coverage. Our guide to wedding photography styles walks through every approach with honest pros and cons. It’s worth reading before you move forward, because choosing a style is the decision underneath all the other decisions.

At some point in phase one you’ll start running into pricing. Wedding photography costs vary widely, and understanding why before you filter too aggressively is worth the time. We’ve written a breakdown of how much wedding photography costs in Wisconsin that covers the real reasons behind the numbers.

Here’s the advice that’s hardest to give: consider looking at at least one photographer who seems out of your budget. We say this knowing it results in more long-shot inquiries for photographers like us, but if it were someone we cared about, we’d say it anyway. The higher end of the market tends to mean more experience, more consistency, and more trust that the day is handled. That might genuinely be worth adjusting your budget for. It’s always a question of what you value most, and spending more on one vendor means spending less somewhere else, so only you can make that call. But don’t filter out a photographer you love without at least knowing what they cost.

One more thing while we’re here: if you inquire with a photographer and end up going with someone else, please send a quick note letting them know. It sounds small, but it genuinely matters. Photographers follow up, hold dates, and sometimes turn away other inquiries. A two-sentence email goes a long way.

By the end of phase one you should have three to five photographers whose work you genuinely love and who are roughly in range.


Phase 2: Get on a Call

Figuring out if the style and personality are actually a match

A portfolio tells you what a photographer has made. A conversation tells you how they work, how they think, and whether you’d want to spend one of the most emotionally loaded days of your life with them. Different things, and both matter.

Book calls with your shortlist. Most photographers offer them for free, and any photographer worth booking welcomes the conversation. If you can, do a video call with both of you present. How a photographer talks to you as a couple, not just as a booking, tells you a lot.

Don’t approach this as an interview with a checklist. Let it be a conversation. The best calls feel like two parties figuring out if they’re a good fit, not one party pitching and one party evaluating. That said, there are a few things worth having in the back of your mind going in.

How do they approach the day? This is the one topic most couples never get to, and it’s the most useful answer you’ll get. You want to understand where they fall between observing and orchestrating. Do they see their job as documenting what happens, or directing what happens? Neither is wrong, but the answer shapes how your day will feel and what ends up in your gallery. If you haven’t already read our guide to wedding photography styles, this is the conversation that’ll make it click.

How much time do they need for portraits? Some photographers want forty-five minutes or more with just the two of you. Others work in fifteen. It affects your timeline, your reception, and how much of your wedding day is spent doing something other than being at your wedding.

How do they handle family formals? If those matter to you, ask specifically. How long does it typically take? Do they work from a list, or do they expect you to round people up? This is one of the most reliably chaotic parts of a wedding day, and a photographer with a clear approach to it makes a real difference.

What happens if something goes wrong? Equipment fails. Photographers get sick. A professional has a backup plan ready. If this question catches someone off guard, that’s information.

What does delivery look like? How many images, and how long does it take? These vary a lot and it’s better to know upfront.

Pay attention to whether they ask questions about you. Some photographers will send a short questionnaire before the call to get to know you first. That’s a good sign. It means they’re thinking about fit, not just trying to close a booking. A photographer who’s genuinely curious about you before the call has probably been paying that kind of attention for a long time.

Personality fit is real. You’re going to spend more time with your photographer than almost anyone else on your wedding day. If the call feels like a sales pitch, or if you feel like you’re being talked into something, notice that.


Phase 3: Can You Actually Trust Them?

The final decision

By the end of phase two you know whether you love their work and whether you like them. What you don’t yet know is whether you can trust them. That’s what phase three is for.

The best evidence is a full wedding gallery. Not a highlights reel or a curated portfolio, but a complete set from one wedding, start to finish. Most photographers will share one on request. If a photographer is hesitant to do this, that’s worth noting. A complete gallery shows you what you’ll actually receive: how consistent they are across different moments and lighting conditions, what the quieter parts of the day look like, whether the quality holds up at 9pm on a dance floor the way it does during golden hour portraits.

Look at the full gallery the way you’d look at a contractor’s finished project. Not just the best parts, but everything in between.

Read reviews carefully, not just for praise but for specifics. “They were so easy to work with and made us feel completely comfortable” tells you something real. “The photos were beautiful” tells you less. Look for reviews that describe how the photographer actually worked on the day.

Pay attention to how they communicate. How quickly did they respond to your inquiry? Were their emails clear? Did they answer your questions directly? How a photographer communicates before you book is a reliable preview of how they’ll communicate in the months leading up to your wedding.

Read the contract before you sign it. Understand what’s included, what isn’t, what happens if they need to cancel, when your gallery will be delivered, and who owns the images. If anything is unclear, ask. A straightforward contract from a photographer who answers questions about it without hesitation is a good sign.

Ask how long they’ve been shooting weddings and roughly how many they’ve done. Experience doesn’t automatically mean quality, but consistency builds over time. Someone who has photographed forty weddings has seen more go sideways than someone who has photographed five, and they’ve figured out how to handle it.

If budget is still a factor in the final decision, think about what you’d actually regret. Flowers, food, the open bar: those live in memory. Your photos don’t. We’re not saying spend more than you can afford. We’re saying be honest with yourself about what matters when the day is over.


Making the Call

Once you’ve done all three phases, you usually know. If you’ve found someone whose work you love, whose approach matches what you want, and who you genuinely trust to show up and handle the day, book them.

If you’re still wavering between two, ask yourself which photographer’s full gallery you’d rather have on the wall ten years from now. That usually answers it.


Where We Come In

We’re Ray and Kelly, documentary and candid wedding photographers near Madison, Wisconsin. We’ve been photographing weddings together for almost twenty years. That experience does something that’s hard to put in a portfolio: it puts couples at ease. We’ve seen enough wedding days to know how to read one, move through it, and be where we need to be before things happen. We don’t just show up and shoot. We walk through the day with you.

If you’re drawn to photography that documents your wedding as it actually happens, real emotion, real moments, minimal posing, we’d love to hear from you.

If after reading this you’re realizing you want something more structured or directed, there are great photographers who specialize in exactly that and you’ll be better served by one of them. Finding the right fit matters more than finding us.

For where this decision sits among all the others, our Wisconsin wedding planning guide lays the whole thing out in sequence, from the date forward.

Either way, we hope this helped.

We're on a treasure hunt for beauty. We want our images to take you right back to the grand moments of your day, and to the milliseconds that flew past, the ones you couldn't stop to breathe and look around and appreciate while they were happening. We don't invent those moments. We recognize them.

Our couples trust us to document the people and moments that matter most to them, which frees them up to spend the day with each other instead of with us.

We're rooted near Viroqua, in Wisconsin's Driftless Region, a small foodie-and-outdoors town that shaped how we see beauty in everyday moments. From there we travel across the state, with Madison and Door County among our most-photographed areas, alongside Milwaukee, Spring Green and La Crosse. Fifteen+ years in, we still don't take the trust of a wedding day lightly.

more about us!

we are ray + kelly!